Reviews, News, and How To Geeks

Download Our Windows 7 Tips!

I've been a long time Ubuntu and Linux user. Don't get me wrong, I try to use as many different operating systems as often as I can, but primarily on my machines, I've been using Ubuntu or some variant of Ubuntu for around 4 years now.

People ask me, why use Linux? I tell them, it's fun. To me, using Linux is somewhat of an ongoing never ending project to make your computer work best. And whats different of that rather than in Windows or Mac is that on Linux the job is on your shoulders to do so. It's not for your average person by any means and I never tell anyone "Oh you should put Linux on that computer."

That being said, I am writing this post from within Windows 7.

Yep, I've recently dropped Ubuntu and opted to make Windows 7 my primary workspace environment. Now the question is, why? The answer; to put it short, Ubuntu 9.10 was... balls. Very balls.

From the moment I installed Karmic Koala it gave me nothing but problems. Battery life was much worse than before (and it already was pretty bad), I couldn't get my computer to suspend, on boot up I was presented with a notification that things were going wrong and I couldn't make them go away, I didn't like the new software center thing I felt it was much slower than the old system, and overall, it was just... balls.

What's worse is; I helped! I did bug testing for Karmic Koala while it was in Alpha, I was very excited for the release of it because it's something I contributed to, I loved 9.04 and the previous versions I used and now I have the skills to contribute to the project and then end results, it's crap.

I wanted to love Karmic Koala more than anything, but it was just balls. Easily the worse OS I've used in recent memory, worse than Vista, on the same level as Windows ME I'd even say.

So, I was thinking about it, and in the end I figured whenever I used the Windows 7 beta, I was always impressed, my buddy who's just as much into Ubuntu as I am told me that he isn't using Ubuntu at all anymore, that he's put Windows 7 on all his primary machines. So I put Windows 7 on my primary laptop, and for the most part, it's been a great experience.

It's very surreal though, going back to mainly using Windows again. Whenever I did a clean install of Linux, drivers was always a project to get done. When I installed Windows, I was going through all the stuff I normally did on Linux for video drivers and such, out of curiosity, I clicked Windows update, and bam, there's the drivers, install, restart, done.

Also, not configuring games in Wine is a real time saver. I was able to put in Morrowind, install the game and my mods, and be off on the way. No manually editing config files to make a nearly 8 year old game playable on relatively new hardware.

And battery life. My Lord! The one thing I've always missed about Windows compared to Linux was battery life. I'll keep this simple: on Ubuntu, even after configuring and running various scripts and power management programs: 3.5 hours. On Windows 7 with no special configuration: 7.5 hours.

So who knows, maybe Ubuntu 10.04 will be better and I'll be using that one when it comes out. I know I'll give it a try. I know I won't contribute to the project for the next release though. I also know that my server is going to stay on Ubuntu 9.04. But until Ubuntu 10.04 comes out, I'm sticking with Windows 7, and I'm damn impressed with it and it's being a great OS.

So until next time, remember true believers; skys are sunny, bees make honey, and don't you go changing.

Tags: 7, 9.10, beta, karmic, koala, operating, os, system, ubuntu, windows

Share

 

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of Reviews, News, and How To Geeks to add comments!

Join this Ning Network

Andrew DePersio Comment by Andrew DePersio on November 17, 2009 at 7:16pm
@Eric T

It wasn't getting the drivers to work in Ubuntu was a problem, it's the fact that it was a bit of a chore to do you know. The driver utility in it never really worked good for me, so to install the video driver, you know I'd have to go to the site, download the driver, drop to the terminal, then stop x window (and I could never remember the command, so I'd have to look it up), run the .sh file, wait for everything to configure.

It was by no means undo-able, but in Windows it was just, Windows update, install, done. And it was just weird after going through that process for so long to have it that simplified.

I get what you mean though about a new OS being buggy, but I installed 9.04 right away too and it wasn't near as buggy for me.

I guess this post wasn't really an attack on Ubuntu or praising Windows so much, because honest to God, I never hated Windows, and I don't hate Ubuntu now. Really, this post is more of me coming back to Windows and realizing how much easier some things are than from in Linux. But there's a hell of a lot of things I miss from Linux (such as smaller footprint, and installing programs with apt-get)
Eric T Comment by Eric T on November 17, 2009 at 1:39pm
So what drivers weren't working for you in 9.10 (or 9.04)? My experience of recent versions of Ubuntu v Vista is that driver support is actually better overall in Ubuntu than Windows nowadays, especially any hardware that's more than a couple of years old, and especially for 64-bit.

Most of the issues with 9.10 will get fixed over the next few months - I certainly never upgrade straight away because the latest release of every Ubuntu always has its share of issues.

Windows 7 is really just Vista SP3 with some performance tweaks - the core OS is exactly the same as Vista, so many of its issues have already been ironed out.
Jordan Keyes Comment by Jordan Keyes on November 17, 2009 at 1:26pm
I'm inclined to agree the Ubuntu 9.10 is a bit of a disaster, but I'd hardly compare it to Windows Vista or ME. Most of the issues I've seen so far are related to the switch to devicekit for everything, and the deprecation of HAL. My battery life is actually better, but it doesn't detect that the battery needs charging until it's lost quite a bit of charge.

The biggest thing to keep in mind is, this is not a "long term support" version, meaning they take a lot more risks and more things have the possibility to fail. A complete replacement of the hardware abstraction layer is bound to come with some bugginess, but that's to be expected. If you want 100% stability, 8.04 is still a great option, and even 9.04. I'm still on 9.10 with my laptop and netbook, but I intend to keep my desktop at 9.04 until more issues are resolved.
Alex Fjeldsted Comment by Alex Fjeldsted on November 15, 2009 at 8:03pm
Cool ^^ i didn't like the previous version

Sign in

E-mail

Password
 or Sign Up
By signing in, you agree to the amended Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Forgotten your password?

Geek Out!




More Information


© 2009   Created by Chris Pirillo

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Privacy  |  Terms of Service